Back
The important role of real estate appraisals
Aug 18, 2017

by Deana Halladay

Real estate appraisals play an important role in any real estate market, but even more so when prices are rising or new developments are popping up in your neighbourhood like never before.

But how exactly does an appraiser determine value in such a crazy market and what factors do they examine?

“One of the key methods in valuing a residential property involves comparing properties that have recently sold within the neighbouring area that offer similar characteristics to the property being valued,” explained Deana Halladay, CRA, president of the Appraisal Institute of Manitoba.

“Since the objective of the appraisal is to estimate the price the subject property would most likely sell for if exposed to the marketplace, recent sales of similar properties are used for comparison and as benchmarks. Comparable sales represent what other informed buyers in the marketplace are willing to pay for similar features, location and amenities.”

Where recent sales in the immediate area may be lacking, the appraiser can analyse past sales and expand the search to surrounding neighbourhoods offering similar characteristics to the subject area.

“Appraisers obtain their market information from various sources, including Multiple Listing Services® (MLS®) listings, land title registries, private data service providers, private sales (sales by owners), assessment information and various other sources,” said Halladay. “As per the Appraisal Institute of Canada’s professional standards, commonly known as the Canadian Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (CUSPAP), an appraiser must conduct a three-year sales history and a one-year listing history search and analysis of the property.”

One of the other elements that appraisers consider are the zoning restrictions. Attention is given to the potential of high-density developments being built within an existing neighbourhood, either on a vacant site or where a structure has reached the end of its economic life. This is an important factor to consider, however, it doesn’t automatically mean a decrease in home value.

Although many homeowners automatically embrace a “not in my backyard” mentality, what many don’t realize is that high-density developments can often translate into increased overall property value in a neighbourhood.

For example, purchasers in a new small condo development are often first-time home buyers.  Those condo owners may eventually become single-family homeowners, so they provide a move-up market as they know the neighbourhood they are buying into. 

Whatever the “story” is of a particular neighbourhood or property, an appraiser can provide a methodical, process-based approach that encompasses due diligence, research and analysis of key market and property data to REALTORS®. This objective opinion can help them better understand the property’s sales and listing history and the estimated time to sell the property (exposure time).

The appraisal gives independent insight on purchaser behaviour and supply and demand for similar properties that a Realtor can consider, and potentially share with their clients to assist in making important real estate decisions.

It will also detail structural characteristics and condition, assessment data, title restrictions, zoning and land use controls, to name a few.

“In a market where ethics and professionalism are of paramount importance, having a third-party involved to provide an unbiased opinion on the value of a property is a strategy that many Realtors employ to demonstrate their integrity and their willingness to add value to their client,” added Halladay.

(Deana Halladay is the president of Appraisal Institute of Canada — Manitoba.)